22 May 2009

Torture Cels

An ultra-conservative talk-show host in Chicago let himself be waterboarded to debunk the idea that such practices are torture. He came out singing the "I've been Tortured" lullaby, unequivocally stating that water-boarding is torture. He drowned as a child, and had to be revived. Waterboarding doesn't simulate drowning, he said: it is drowning.

Further evidence that God has both a sense of justice and irony.

Christopher Hitchens of Slate and Vanity Fair underwent the same experiment and came to the same conclusion.

Gertrude Stein put it best: "a rose is a rose is a rose".

And torture is torture is torture.

Shakespeare wrote that "a rose by any other name would smell as sweet." Unfortunately, the converse is as true: torture cloaked in the semantics of "enhanced interrogation techniques" still reeks to the high heavens like a pig farm surrounded by fields of rotting cabbage.

Not only does torture diminish our stature as a country, it makes us collectively responsible for it.

I wish Ms. Stein had said "wrong is wrong is wrong." Or as I've said many times, "Enough is enough is always enough."

And I've had enough.

More than enough.

No comments: